Agree with what's been said....
They're great for warm weather months, only way to keep shiners alive I've found.
But the only time I've found them necessary in the winter is on the coldest days, the aerator keeps the bucket from freezing solid. Only thing is, the batteries run out fast when it's that cold.
As for keeping minis alive, I have really good luck just changing the H2O in my bucket once a day & keeping it in the garage (just above 32*) no food, no aeration aside from water changes. An average of 4 per day die....I have minis in my bucket right now over 1 month old and still going strong. (fatheads, big suckers, and big shiners)
Obviously, they won't last as long in the summer due to warmer temps, but I have kept them from one weekend to the next using the aerator in the summer. The batteries last longer than I expected, around 3 days in mine.
post edited by Pork - 2010/02/16 11:51:18