Greenlick Dam(Jacobs Creek Park)

I think 98% of the carp in that place are less than 15 lbs...

Most carp are 3-7 pound with an occasional 10 pounder. A few years back I was fishing for cats/eyes with 5 inch suckers and caught two carp around 15 pound each, but that was rare. Most cats 16 - 20 inch with an occasional bigger one. In the fall of 1997 I caught a 27 pound flathead there and returned it to the lake. With a little luck it may still be swimmin there, haven't heard of anyone catching a "big one" there. 
 
You're right about it being feast or famine. Sometimes it's like the dead sea.

Do you fish from shore or boat Wally?

This year only did good around dusk. Caught 2 northern pike under 23" but no carp.

my brother caught a nice sized catfish out of there, it was about 2 foot long and pretty fat.  Had some strange colors tho, it kinda looked like a rainbow from the coloring. He caught that on a worm fishing for perch.

Where abouts is Greenlick Dam?

Outskirts of Mt. Pleasant....

The two 15 pound carp I caught there were caught on creek chubs while fishing for eyes/catfish. Carp will get bait shy after being caught a couple of times on a particular flavor/scent of doughball and may even totally stay away from any doughball. I think that's why I caught those two on chubs. The chubs may even have been dead.

Ya'll talkin bout the one with Soccer fields right? or you talking about the actual park isn't it like bridgeport 2 or w/e? The other name...

Ahhh the real one. Bridgeport 2 and 1 are up near there and I think some people call that Bridgeport 3 or something unless i'm mistaken...

Awesome then I was right... Anyone do any good there or is it an on and off lake like a dead sea one day then pretty good the next?

I hit it early Sunday morning.  Nothing, in fact it barely even showed signs of life.

I tried it again Monday morning.  Pannies & bass cruising all over the shallows.  I couldn't get them to even look at anything I threw out there.  I didn't see anyone else pulling anything in either.

Anyone doing any good here lately, thinking of trying it for bass on Saturday, never been there.

It's about 45 min for me. Other options i had were virgin run, cannonsburgh (blah), acme, and dunlap.

Go to acme and donegal if you're going for bass you may get a saugeye or musky at donegal also. And some cats... I'm headin to donegal tonite till probably midnight or so i'll let ya'll know how it goes and maybe get some pics hopefully.