Great local bait shop
Not sure if this place has been mentioned before, and I'm too lazy to look. But Hank's bait on route 9, between exits 10 and 11 is great. Not only is his bait lively and lasts months if kept properly. But since he's seen me come in regularly, he's taking care of me big time. $3.50 for a "dozen". I just got home and counted how many were in my dozen. 38 not counting 2 tiny runts. I'm not trying to advertise for this guy, but definitely would suggest going there if he's within your range.
Only problem would be explaining to Mr. DEC about having a receipt for a dozen, when I've got over 3 dozen.
When hell freezes over, I'll fish there too.