RE: Wader Question/Suggestions
2009/10/24 10:46:30
(permalink)
Just my opinion, so take it for what it's worth. I started with low end breathable models when they first came out and worked my way up through the top of the line Simms, LL Bean and Orvis models over the years. I got the same use/wear out of high end and low end waders, absolutely no difference in durablility or time between buying and developing leaks in high wear areas (basically seams). What I did get out of the higher end models that I didn't in the low end models was foot fit in the neoprene foot. Cheaper models had much bigger feet than I needed and the expensive models had a much better fit for me (size 10).
I've also found out that the thinner (less layers) the better for breathability, meaning I stayed dry inside from condensation.
The more expensive models offer a warrenty, which I've used on every pair I've bought, due to seam leaks.
Orvis had a better policy than Simms in my opinion. I just returned the waders to the store and exchanged them. Simms I always had to send back. While talking to the folks as Simms they actually told me that I used their boots too much (supposedly built for guides) and that I should buy 2 pair of their boots to lengthen the time they last. (I haven't bought Simms since).
I'm currently using a pair of of Bailey's boots and love them. They're the "Bare Bones" model, ultra light, very breathable, good fit for me and under $150. I'll buy another pair when the time comes.
Ultimately the only reason I don't buy the Hodgeman pair for $75-100 is the foot size. In the size I wear they usually have a size 12 or so foot that is too bunchy for my liking in the wading shoe. For the money, they'll do everything my high end big name boots did, but they just didn't fit me well.
Fishing with bait is like swearing in church.
Slate Drake