JEB,
between me and my cat fishing buds, we haven't had any luck using shrimp anywhere else. Lotta skunks behind that statement.
Lake Erie, I have tried everything and everything 3 times more. shrimp has proven the most consistent, but at times and in certain conditions other baits will perform better. My theory is that the shrimp is a substitute for crayfish feeding catfish...only logical explanation I can offer.