Porktown, I don't know squat about trolling motors, but if I may, I would apply a little automotive engineering to the problem. Vehicles either use relays or drivers to distribute electrical power to various loads, and your motor has similarities. Drivers are transistorized; high side drivers supply current, low side drivers provide ground. A relay normally has two powers and a ground, and the output to the load. When you hear clicking, you may be hearing the relay pulling down as it's supposed to, but it's possible the problem is on the output side of the relay. One post of a relay would be B+(12V or 24V), (Heavy wire),one post would be B+ from a switch or other source, (smaller wire), the other post would be the ground, (small wire), and the 4th post is the output, (heavy wire). When B+ comes from the switch, (ie: foot pedal) or ground comes from the switch, however the pedal is wired, the power is pulled low to ground and the coil closes, allowing the high current to flow through the relay to the load. Speeds from the foot pedal would be from a rheostat, (or a resistive multiplex unit; we call it MUX), and would vary the amount of the ground to the motor through the resistor. Find what's clicking when you hit the trigger, then with DVOM check for output voltage on that unit. If you have voltage, then use something like an old headlight, (something that will pull some amps to test the wire) and see if it lights brightly. If it lights but is dim, you're looking for high resistance in that circuit, ie: corrosion or weak wire, bad solder joint, or possibly a burnt trace on the board. Good luck!