Thanks for the suggestions.
Pachuckles, yeah thats one of the reasons why I checked out Tamarack that one night. Maybe I just wasn't in the right spot or they just weren't hitting or something.
KingKool, where on Tionesta Creek? I've fished the parts above the lake for trout, and I fished the outflow a few times in the summer and only got a few gills and rock bass. I wasn't really fishing on the bottom though.