ORIGINAL: troutslammer
i know everyone on here argues the point of whats wadable at kinzua but all i can say is this , i weigh 160 lbs (float relatively easy ) and anything above 1500 cfs of discharge is too much for me to safely navigate to wherever i want to go (like across from 59 side to dixon island , when i say wadable i mean from one bank to the other so when you decide after you go up then u will find out what is your confort zone and maybe your definition of wadable means 10 feet out from shore too ......so .....
no there's no argument is there?
I can wade
shore to shore at 2200 cfs near the bottom of the dixon island rapids. its challenging but doable. I'm not saying anyone can do it, and I certainly would'nt recommend to a newbe, but after a few trips you get the why and the whats about the main run at dixon island. stay off of shiftable rocks, keep sidewides to minimize the force of the current and lean into it slightly. I also didn't rush it and took my time to make sure I really wanted to try it.
I'm 180. so its not a matter of being heavy.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
as for your definition of wadable, what do I say? if your in the water, your wading. (thats what the fish cops think). you can do that somewhere on the tailwaters all 365days of the year. IMHO, its a wierd definition.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
but no one ever said that you could cross the dixon island rapids at 14,000
. but then again, there's more than one good spot in the tailwaters; and they change as the seasons/water levels do..... so "Wading" 10' (sissy as it sounds) just might be the difference between 10 winter walleye and none.
anyways from a liability point of view I have no idea how good a lurker/regular/visiting angler is wading. I would never urge anyone to go to a place he didn't think he/she could handle. you've got to be confident and careful. I'm sure you need to add a little extra caution for episodes of rising water, although normally water doesn't rise very much (it oscillates up and down, as someone in the post said) in a short period of time.
HOWEVER, they clearly are times where they make dramatic changes in water level and you should (must) be able to get out of deeper /faster water when they do. luckily those times are very rare.
be safe but be confident. beginners should test the water and in sunlight to see where they can go. if you only can get out 10'; you're still fishing water you can't fish 10' ago. don't be like expecting too easily go everywhere below the signs, but don't make this sound like ohiopyle (or major rapids).
it isn't.