2014/10/18 22:28:40
Eman89so
I have 5 to 6 people that next year we are looking to go out of state to hunt trophy whitetails with a bow..does anyone have any recommendations on where to go? what state should be looked at? Guided hunt? Public?
2014/10/19 07:22:41
Eman89so
We are leaning towards self guided hunt. Just need to pick a state
2014/10/19 09:42:27
BeenThereDoneThat.
Regardless of where, when, how, etc. Do your homework 'well' before you commit. Many dreams have been made and so have nightmares. Various states offer public land for hunting however, access to that land may be limited or impossible. You may choose to hunt a non-guided reserve only to pay more even though unsuccessful. Speaking of reserves, make certain to get ALL cost up front before you shoot their trophy buck. (is it a trophy?) Venison can get really pricey when it is sporting a hat rack. Least not forget, should you opt for a guide, gratuities are expected.

Having traveled literally two million plus miles across Americas highways and byways I have to say 'The Buckeye' impresses me the most when speaking of whitetail. Time and time again I would see awesome heavily racked deer in the fields and woods. Many times these deer were in groups feeding along the highway. I often wonder just what a trophy would be if what I was seeing was common to the area. Conversation with locals while making deliveries, as to open land for hunting, didn't reveal a serious problem with getting access to public or private land. Archery would not be a problem, especially, in those areas limited to shotgun and bow hunting.

I'll certainly stand corrected when I say W.VA. is most likely the most difficult to access private land and, public land is usually surrounded by private land.

Definitely check the web sights as some states offer free hog hunting as an incentive to visit.

Just do your homework WELL before.
2014/10/19 12:23:01
S-10
Eman- you have mail
2014/10/19 16:30:36
DRod
I lived in Kentucky from '98-'01 during grad school.  Very good public hunting opportunities with the bow, and is often one of those second tier trophy states mentioned in the outdoors media.  I lived just south of Lexington and hunted about 40 miles west on private property (mostly) near Taylorsville Lake.  Saw many quality bucks at check stations and deer processors, and saw the biggest buck I've ever seen on the hoof there during archery season one year.  
 
Not sure if things are still the same, but when I was there:
 
State WMA's (Wildlife Management Areas - their version of our SGL's) were wide open to archery hunters but restricted in gun season to a lottery system.  The times I bow hunted on WMA's, I rarely saw other hunters.  Deer densities were not real high in many areas back then, but trophy potential was pretty significant.  
 
As BTDT referenced with regards to WV, private property was very difficult to get into.  A friend and I lucked into a 260 acre farm when we stopped to ask for directions to the Taylorsville Lake WMA one day.  What I was told - not sure if it's true - was to NEVER venture onto private property that I didn't have permission to be on because of the high concentration of marijuana grows in the state.  Pot was at the time the #1 cash crop in KY.  
 
Seems that Western KY is a popular destination for trophy hunters, and also northern KY along the Ohio River.  
2014/10/19 19:42:20
dakota kid
I lived in South Dakota for a while. I would say it was the best deer hunting I ever experienced. They don't have a lot of records coming out of the state, but the number of deer is overwhelming. On average the bucks out there were larger than here, but the number of hunters was way lower. I passed 12 different bucks before I shot mine at noon on the first day. I was hunting public land(archery only) and never saw another hunter. They also sell an any deer tag good for whitetails and mule deer. There are certain areas where you can find both, like a few spots in the black hills. You can also get tags for pronghorn and elk as well. If you are entertaining the idea of a 23 hour drive, pm me and I'll tell you a few good spots.
2014/10/22 15:44:18
Eman89so
I like all the ideas
2014/11/21 09:39:36
dakota kid
I'll be working in Missouri during their second archery season. $225 for a two deer/ two turkey tag. I already have my area picked in one of the counties with the highest harvest numbers. 30,000 acres with no camping restrictions. Lots of man made water holes and grazing areas. I was able to see the well used deer trails from Google earth. I already picked a tree for the climber. My leave date is Dec. 4th. I'll let you know how it goes. 
 
On a side note, my last trip was to Illinois. I would loved to have hunted there, but there's very little public land and the tags were $450 for one buck. I did take a walk one afternoon behind the hotel just to see what I could find. I had a 13 point(almost worth $450) and a 10 point within 20 yards neither seemed to notice me. I assume the rut had something to do with it, but I'd say all the deer I saw seemed less spooky than PA deer. I saw a stand, so the area gets some pressure.
 
The biggest buck I saw on the road this last trip was just off the highway near the fairview exit, a really heavy horned half rack, five or six on the one side. I'm wondering how he lost the other antler. If it was due to fighting, I'd love to see the other guy.
2014/11/22 09:22:21
bingsbaits
Eman, if you decide on which state let me know.
I have a stack of those Atlas and Gazeteer maps for many of the central states from when I was planning on going out that way.
Have; Indiana, Ohio, Wisconsin, Michigan, Illinois and Colorado.
2014/11/24 09:06:07
dakota kid
I'm waiting on pins and needles to see this buck Eman. Lets see this guy. I was on the road working for the last week of the season and want to live vicariously through my fellow hunters. 
12

Use My Existing Forum Account

Use My Social Media Account