Actually, in NYS, if you are looking under rocks in a trout stream, it is a violation to use anything you find for bait. When I last bought a PA license~30 years ago, you could gather up to 50 of any invertebrate per day for personal use for bait. Conventional methods like running the larva through with the hook point tends to really mess up a lot of these soft critters, but I watched a guy hammer fish in the 900 on Spring Creek in Caledonia once, and when I asked what he was using, he told me leeches that he was digging out of the cress roots. These are small, no more than 1/4" long. He had a size 14 fly hook and he was attaching them to the hook with a drop of superglue. If he couldn't find a leech, he glued on a scud. But you could get a ticket in NY for it, if a warden happened by!
I've always got some green caddis, and some tan caddis, and some orange caddis, in my box when I'm on the SR, and they have worked magic even on kings and browns in the fall when bigger stuff was not working. Fichy is right on with that tip!
L13