I know I told this story before but just so happens I was reading about this guide today discussing rotating.
One morning I get to this sweet spot at O'dark thirty. I'm sitting there and just before light I see headlamps coming down the trail.
They head straight for me and the guide says " we want to make a movie and would it be ok for his clients to fish " my spot". I told him I been sitting here for awhile waiting for light to fish this spot. I would be glad to rotate ( meaning fish for a little while then rotate) with your clients if they started at the top and fished down for awhile. He said ok . Well I hooked up right away and asked if they wanted to fish here. He said no not yet. Well after catching another he for sure wanted to fish there so I moved to the top. Thing was they did not hook up and didn't want to move after planting there. I fished about an hr and then asked what happened to rotating, his response was once they caught a fish for their movie they would. I left and lost all respect for the guide.
Now what brings me back to this thread is on his website he complains that people won't rotate a run/ pool .
Like said, I'm willing to share water and when asked I do and also ask others myself. Simple answer will be yes or no. To make it a mandatory rule , I wish no part of that style of fishing myself and do not wish to fish any water that rule happens.