Ever catch what I would call a surprise catch ? Good or bad stories.... all apply.
 
We were fishing Shenango Lake in the late 60's as teens from shore, just tossing worms for the usual Bass and Catfish. My buddy hooks into a fish that's jumping like crazy. Next thing we are looking at a nice Brook Trout on shore ! What is this guy doing in here? I guess he did a down stream paddle from Little Shenango Creek about 10 miles or more away. Only Trout I've ever seen caught out of that lake ever.  
 
* Might get a lot more Trout in the lake now days since they now started to stock Trout in New Hamburg (upper Shenango River) just a mile or so above the lake.  

I caught a brook trout at new Hamburg around 20 years ago. Only one I've ever seen there. I don't see why they'd stock trout in that part of the river unless they just want to feed the pike and musky.

http://www.sharonherald.com/news/fish-will-be-biting/article_9ca8ef11-f6de-51ed-ae53-3e1c63626057.html

18" brown trout caught inside of an under the road pipe while fishing for catfish bait in the city.

Caught a trout at the cover bridge many years ago

wow amazing

a huge pacu in a public pond     guess someone didnt want it as a pet anymore

Heyyyy Captain..... I caught a live fish once. Honest!

Oddest was freshwater clams and fishing poles.

a good story from one of our trips to northern Ontario:
 
www.walleyecentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=366265&highlight=kearns
 
phish