i started fishing pymy in the early to mid 70s and within ten years i was fishing there up to 100 times a year. gas was cheap and i had no responsibilities other than to myself. what a time it was. i swear i waded every foot of the south end on the ohio side and most of the north. what a time it was. we would use size 11 floating raps in silver color, painted with a few coats of clear finger nail polish for walleyes in the spring and fall. the limits were 8 fish and a minimum of 13 inches back then. countless nights it was easy to limit out on fish around 20 inches. as soon as the fish moved back into deeper waters, we pursued them by trolling or drifting with harnesses, homemade of course, as well as cp swings tipped with crawlers. floating jigs were also on the menu, rigged as a slip rig. there was an island off of poplar grove picnic grounds back then (now completely eroded away) and the fish would hang off of the shoal. we pounded them there with a north or south wind. later we would fish the onion field on the north end and off of clark, harris and whaley islands. just awesome slab and walleye fishing.
as summer waned, the smallmouth fishing would explode. we'd nail really nice fish, up to 22 inches, on size nine floating raps and shallow running shad raps, once they were introduced.
that lake has always been so generous to me. i know i paid my dues but she never forgot. such great memories.