Captain Hook....don't feel the need to justify yourself for keeping that fish. It was a nice one! Guys are always going to rag on people for catching fish but the reality is we each have a choice. Like you I'm not interested at all in a replica. On another board (about muskie I believe) someone mentioned snapping a picture of a huge buck and getting a replica for the wall mounted. Funny how many people have different opinions about keeping fish and killing the deer.
I think you made a great choice, whoever mounted it looks like they did a great job, and that's going to look awesome on your wall! Congrats again!