Been fishing Shenango for eyes and ran into a small muskie last week.  22 inches and skinny as all get out.  Fished Monday and caught him again.  He tore part of his right lip the first time I caught him, so I know it was the same fish.  Went out today and yep got him again.  Same tore lip.  The fish was caught all 3 times within a half mile of the first place I caught him, 2 times on one side of the lake and the last time on the opposite side of the lake.  All 3 times he hit a gold and black hot n tot, all 3 times at the same 15' depth.  I did get one of his larger brothers today also, a 29 incher. 

its like the rapala commercial lol

So how is the walleye fishing? Never tried for walleye there. Always just went for crappie. Thanks!

Some fish never learn!

The eye fishing was really good last month.  Just getting back into the swing of things now that the water has come down.  Neighbor has been doing good with crawlers and jigs on the humps in the afternoon.  Seems to be like Pymie Jr. for me, a lot of fish but most of them are short.

Thats crazy, 3X's the same fish, same lake, two different locations... I've caught the same fish out of the same hole on a creek.
Pretty cool, too bad he wasn't bigger...
But it still counts as 3 muskies... haha !
 
I wonder how many other guys caught him in that same time frame as well ????