Try calling Forest Hardware, on the main drag through Tionesta. Was up there earlier this week and believe they had a canoe / kayak rental sign out front. It's worth a shot......
814.755.3531
I know you're looking near President, but maybe they let you haul the things away yourself....
FYI - anyone familiar with the area, looking to launch at Nebraska Bridge - be warned, if the "Road Closed" signs are up, the Corps of Engineer folks are writing citations for being down there. FoCo Sheriff dept just giving verbal warnings.....
Tough having fun up there anymore (thank the dang Ohesian who submerged his car this past winter)