Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (Full Version)

All Forums >> [Pennsylvania Boards] >> Northwest PA



Message

crappiechuck -> Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/18/2008 10:49:01 PM)

I can't decide.



rapala11 -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTE" better? Opinions! (4/18/2008 10:49:42 PM)

perch



crappiechuck -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/18/2008 10:55:07 PM)

Perch is real good. Crappie flakey. Perch firm, Gills sweet. If they spliced the three together the perfect eating fish. Still.... I can't decide.



nightowl207 -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/19/2008 12:00:58 AM)

perch are my personal favorite. depending on how you cook them they all can taste the same, but if you take all three and fry them with butter, perch is the least fishy tasting.



crazy4ice -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/19/2008 9:33:33 AM)

depends on the time of year u catch them



STEALYS4ME -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/19/2008 6:21:36 PM)

There all good if u make a good batter...



CRAPPIE_SLAYER -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/19/2008 6:31:05 PM)

Love 'em all!



MuskyMastr -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/19/2008 8:32:48 PM)

Crappie and perch are a toss up, gills have a different texture but are almost just as good........

While we are on the subject why not add your least favorite PA fish that you have eaten.

Mine.......LM Bass



flirod4evr -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/19/2008 8:54:11 PM)

A 14" crappie I got below the shenango dam. I fried it up with some perch and it was the fishiest thing I've ever eaten. That crappie did crappies everywhere no justice. But then again it probably swam from downstream by all the mills and what not. Dont eat to many different species of fish.




Kokanee Killer -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/19/2008 10:41:03 PM)

crappies from the dead sea aka glendale [:D]



Bull Lifter -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/19/2008 11:11:15 PM)

perch gills then crappie....i find crappies to be softer..i like the firmer flesh...now that being said i consume my fish from the hard water,m craps tend to be the softest/flakey



WaterWolf -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/20/2008 10:49:21 AM)

Bluegill



JumboPerch#r -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/20/2008 3:36:05 PM)

Neither of them taste as good as bald eagle but I prefer bluegill that have been iced or out of colder water.



crappiechuck -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/20/2008 4:14:05 PM)

Gills are sweet, but hard get on a mess of big ones any more.



flirod4evr -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/20/2008 8:03:14 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: JumboPerch#r

Neither of them taste as good as bald eagle but I prefer bluegill that have been iced or out of colder water.

If I knew you liked bald eagle I would have called you last week when I fried some up, very tastey.[:D]



MuskyMastr -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/20/2008 9:49:32 PM)

Bald eagle is good but not nearly as good as Panda...



JumboPerch#r -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/21/2008 6:55:22 AM)

Thats what I like about this forum just when you think you've gotten as sick as you can ....
Panda, I don't care who you are thats funny right there.
Thanks for the offer for the fry, will post sooner next time



cabst119 -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/21/2008 11:17:22 AM)

My favorite is 6" long filet of smolts from elk creek cooked with garlic and onions.



crappiechuck -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/21/2008 7:08:48 PM)

Slow roasted bbq'd mother in-law beats the **** out of bald eagle any day.  



MuskyMastr -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/21/2008 10:36:35 PM)

Some mother in law's will when cooked on the spit, start one hell of a grease fire.



ShutUpNFish -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/22/2008 6:22:44 AM)

It all tastes like chicken![;)]



Porktown -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/22/2008 10:44:37 AM)

Beaver...  [sm=69.gif]


Of the three listed, perch are probably my favorite fresh water fish.  Too bad they aren't all jumbos.



crappiechuck -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/22/2008 7:48:57 PM)

Blackened red tail tiger carp sure keep you lickin'your fingers and runnin' to the crapper.



Wooden Plug -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/27/2008 11:10:00 AM)

Crappies rule !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Big ole' White fillets.. UM UM GOOD!!!!!!!!!!!



Mikastorm -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (4/28/2008 6:02:12 AM)

Perpiegills are my choice.[image]http://forums.fishusa.com/micons/m6.gif[/image]



OAKHILL 1 -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (5/4/2008 6:23:18 PM)

come on we no that perch sandwich with some tobasco is the best!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



smally hunter -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (5/4/2008 7:58:41 PM)

walleye , haha



CATMAN610 -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (5/5/2008 3:38:45 PM)

they all taste like fish,,,I perfer Van De Kamps.



crappiechuck -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (5/6/2008 1:44:54 PM)

If they could breed a carp with a walleye would't that be great.

Carpeye.

A great tasting fish that gets to be 40lbs and can live, breed, and survive anywhere.

No more boxes of tackle to lug around just a loaf of bread and a can of corn.



CATMAN610 -> RE: Crappie, Perch, or bluegill which TASTES better? Opinions! (5/7/2008 11:30:56 AM)

The sad thing is walleyes don't breed that well in alot of waterways and carp breed like thier first of the month check depends on it.


nice idea though



Page: [1] 2   next >   >>



   

0.141